- About Us
- Wholesale Opportunties
- Blog
- Contact Us
- February Lineup
- Daily Specials
- Special Orders
- Our Location
- Where To Buy
(812) 719-5975
Order Now
Order Now
At Santa Claus Cookie Co., we believe cookies and cupcakes aren’t just desserts; they’re joyful moments that stir nostalgia and bring loved ones together.
Hi, we’re Nikkie and Nick Piszton, the heart and hands behind Santa Claus Cookie Co. Baking isn’t just our job; it’s our lifelong passion, ignited in culinary school and perfected through years of experience. We were drawn to the enchanting town of Santa Claus, Indiana, and inspired to share our love for exceptional cookies with you.
Every cookie is a small batch creation, crafted with locally sourced ingredients and a whole lot of heart. We’re committed to bringing you not just delicious cookies, but a taste of the warmth and joy of our Santa Claus community.
Enjoy the difference of locally sourced ingredients. Fresher taste, higher quality, and support for our community in every bite.
Savor cookies and cupcakes baked with chef-level expertise. Small batches, meticulous detail, and passion you can taste.
Convenience meets deliciousness. Enjoy our magical cookies without leaving your home with easy local delivery.
We're here to make you smile. Expect friendly, helpful service and a truly delightful cookie experience.
Savor sweet white chocolate and a zing of pomegranate in one festive cookie—made to brighten any day with a pop of holiday cheer!
Think steamy hot cocoa in cookie form—loaded with gooey marshmallows, rich chocolate, and all the comforting vibes you crave!
Escape to a tropical paradise with every crunchy bite—our toasted coconut cookie is sunshine in a sweet, buttery package!
Soft, sweet, and sprinkled with cinnamon sugar—our snickerdoodle wraps you in all the cozy vibes of a holiday kitchen!
Go bananas with this chocolaty, banana-flecked treat—our Chunky Monkey cookie delivers a playful crunch and plenty of sweet fun in every bite!
Salty meets sweet in this chocolate chip favorite—sprinkled with sea salt for a melt-in-your-mouth holiday treat!
Amazing! Hands down the best cookie I’ve ever had. Great to see a local company creating such an awesome product!
LOVE the cookies Nick brought by my work. Quick response time and also will deliver to you. Also packaged really nicely. Will be trying again!
Ridiculously GREAT cookies!
Santa Claus Cookie Co., by far, produces the best cookies I have ever had. I have tried them many many times and have never received a bad cookie. AND, not only are the cookies delicious but Nikkie and Nick are super amazing people! So glad they have come into my life!!
Their cookies are baked to perfection. Love the different flavor variations. They are true gourmet cookies that (unfortunately for my waistline) are so delicious! Save your trip to Crumbl, Santa Claus Cookie Co. knocks them out of the park!